American Idol: Who Sang It Better - Terrified

Ok. Somehow, this post of who sang it better will be different. Terrified is a song that has never been performed on the Idol live stage. But since three people related to American Idol already performed this outside of the show, I decided to make this post.

Sure, everyone has their own opinion about this. Kara Dioguardi sang it the way she wrote it - full of soul, which shouldn’t be a surprise since it’s her song to begin with. Katherine McPhee, no doubt, has a technically competent voice to record the song for her new album Unbroken and her version sounded polished and professional, tender and smooth. Didi Benami, on the other hand, made the song completely her own. Her version is by far the most interesting and the emotion is just about right.

So who do you think performed i better?

Videos and Poll after the jump!!

Kara Dioguardi (Lopez Tonight)



Katharine McPhee (The Bonnie Hunt Show)


Didi Benami (The Ellen DeGeneres Show)