American Idol 9: Who's Your Favorite 'Idol' Fifth Placer?

As one more Idol hopeful is eliminated this week, we take a look back at contestants past who were eliminated in the same week. So, who's your favorite 'Idol' Fifth Placer?

Best: Lately (Wildcard)

Worst: Superstition (1970)

Best: I Have Nothing (Movie Hits)

Worst: I Need You (Country Rock)

Best: Take Me To The Pilot (Elton John)

Worst: Tryin' To Get The Feeling Again (Barry Manilow)

Best: Against All Odds (Billboard #1 Hits)

Worst: Impossible Dream (Classic Musicals)

Best: These Foolish Things (Great American Songbook)

Worst: The Way We Were (Love Songs)

Best: Geek In The Pink (Top 20)

Worst: Mayberry (Country)

Best: Let It Be (Lennon-McCartney)
Worst: You Must Love Me (Andrew Lloyd Webber)

Best: So Small (Grand Ole Opry)

Worst: Viva La Vida (Group 2)

Best: You've Got A Way (Shania Twain)

Worst: I'm Already There (Top 16)

Poll after the jump!!