American Idol: Who's Your Favorite 5th Placer?

With Janelle Arthur getting eliminated this week, maybe it's time we look back at contestants past who were eliminated in the same week. So, who's your favorite 'Idol' Fifth Placer?

[Who's Your Favorite Idol 4th Placer?]

RJ Helton

[Season 1]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Lately

Trenyce

[Season 2]
BEST PERFORMANCE: I Have Nothing

George Huff

[Season 3]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Take Me To The Pilot

Scott Savol

[Season 4]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Against All Odds

Paris Bennett

[Season 5]
BEST PERFORMANCE: These Foolish Things

Chris Richardson

[Season 6]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Geek In The Pink

Brooke White

[Season 7]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Let It Be

Matt Giraud

[Season 8]
BEST PERFORMANCE: So Small

Aaron Kelly

[Season 9]
BEST PERFORMANCE: You've Got A Way

Jacob Lusk

[Season 10]
BEST PERFORMANCE: A House Is Not A Home

Skylar Laine

[Season 11]
BEST PERFORMANCE: Where Do Broken Hearts Go

Janelle Arthur

[Season 12]
BEST PERFORMANCE: You Keep Me Hanging On

VOTE!!